
It's a good time, book-wise, to be a tween.
I read the galley of
THE MOTHER-DAUGHTER BOOK CLUB within the first few days after it arrived in our shop. I remember that the Simon galleys arrived late that season and we had less than a week to evaluate them for initial purchase.
As soon as I started TMDBC I knew it would be perfect for us, and it was. We sold...oh, a bajillion copies. We book talked it at schools. We featured it at book fairs. We sold it to girls, their mothers, their grandmothers, their aunts. We urged people to read it together. I don't think there was a tween girl who walked into our shop who left without a copy. (Except there must have been, because then we sold a bajillion of the paperback.)
I was a little wary when I heard a sequel was coming out, as I often am. I DID NOT WANT there to be a sequel to
THE PENDERWICKS. (Until I read it, and then, oh yes, I wanted it.) Sometimes I just want a story to end. I want the characters to stay the ages they are. I don't want the sequels to outgrow the girls.
(And I'm a little afraid of that happening here; in this new book the girls are now in 7th grade, and if they're in 8th grade in the next book...well, then it really needs to end there. Please? Don't age the series any further than that. Please? Don't de-tween it!)
My copy of this book arrived in the mail yesterday. I thought about waiting, as I often do with sequels, in favor of a newer series...but curiosity got the better of me, and I cracked it open this morning. And finished it this evening.
It was really nice to be with Jess, Emma, Cassidy and Megan again. As I stated before, in this book the girls are now in 7th grade and, of course, things are changing for them. Boys are becoming more interesting - to everyone but Cassidy, who sees them as nothing more than hockey and baseball teammates and doesn't understand her friends' growing fascination with the opposite sex. She also doesn't understand her mother's fascination with the opposite sex - her father's only been gone a couple of years; how can her tall, beautiful, ex-model mother be thinking of replacing him with a short bald accountant?
Megan's fascination with clothes and ambition to become a designer is only growing, something her three friends don't really understand. Who DOES understand is her former BFF Becca Chadwick - but snobby, snotty, loudmouthed, popular Becca is loathed by Emma, Jess, and Cassidy. (For good reason, a lot of the time, Megan has to admit - but it's hard to let a best friend go forever.)
Jess's parents finally break down and tell her that they may have to sell their beloved Half Moon Farm. And Emma? Emma's begun to realize that her baby fat isn't going to come off by itself, and that silent crushes can never be anything but crushes.
In the middle of all this turmoil, their mothers reconvene the Mother-Daughter Book Club they started last year. This year, however, the unthinkable happens: Becca Chadwick and her mother are invited to take part. How can Jess, Emma and Cassidy enjoy this place of refuge when their enemy is now in their midst, mocking not only the club itself but this year's book selection,
Anne of Green Gables? How can Megan be friends with her book buddies and her old BFF without alienating anyone? Can the farm be saved? Will Cassidy's mom marry the bald accountant?
Oh, the delicious, nuanced drama.
Frederick never lets her characters descend into hysteria. She obviously remembers what it was like to be a middle-school girl, because she's drawn four very distinct ones here (five if you count Becca). I always knew who was talking without looking at the chapter headings. I love that they're not incredibly similar - several of these friendships were initially forced on them in the first novel, when their mothers (always close) decided that the book club would be the Best. Idea. Ever. The girls aren't incredibly similar, and neither are their mothers, but they're friends anyway, seeing enough in one another to bond over and appreciating what they can learn from their differences.
The friendships aren't perfect, though, because middle-school girls aren't perfect. Frederick doesn't make the mistake of painting rosy pictures of girls skipping hand in hand, off to save the day for one another. They fight and they snap and they hurt and they gossip and they screw up and they apologize awkwardly and they misunderstand, just like everyone does. But at the end of the day, they are a haven for one another, and it's that simple fact that had me closing this worthy sequel with a smile on my face.
Purchase at Powell's or find your local
independent bookstore.