I have known Melissa Anelli, peripherally, for over ten years. Long ago, in another lifetime, we were…ardent? fans of the musical RENT. (We are still fans; we are still ardent; we no longer go almost exclusively by our AOL screen names or sleep out on the streets of Manhattan for $20 tickets. Especially not me. I am old. Melissa was only a teenager back then.) Strangely, we have only met in person once, although we have in recent years kept up fairly well with one another through various forms of online contact. I knew, of course, of her involvement with the Harry Potter phenomenon, but I don’t think I realized just how involved she had gotten until I heard from a mutual friend that she was going to interview J.K. Rowling.
Melissa is the webmistress of The Leaky Cauldron, which has been my go-to site for HP news for as long as I can remember. When I heard that she was writing a book about her experiences in the fandom, I thought, well, that’s one fan memoir I’d actually care to read.
I finally got my hands on a copy and not only read it in one day, but immediately after picked up Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows to re-read (because her book showed me that I’d missed…a lot).
This book is a lot of things. It’s Melissa’s personal journey in the fandom, of course; that is the overarching story, and because she’s been so involved, it’s the right one to tell. The book has been criticized by some in reviews on a well-known non-independent website where one may purchase books (rhymes with glamazon) as being too much about her. Um…it’s a memoir, people. The blurb on the back makes it quite clear that it’s a memoir.
But in addition to being a memoir, it’s a history of wizard rock. A tale of a woman who has devoted part of her life to having HP banned. A tale of websites run entirely by volunteers getting press credentials. A description of what it’s like to be at a fan convention. And yes, a history of HP itself – Jo Rowling’s now-famous backstory; the publishing history of the book worldwide; how the movies came to be; how the book got to be such a phenomenon; what happened after the last words were written. Best of all, it has exclusive interview material AND a foreword by Rowling herself. The stamp of approval, people, right from the very top.
You may have been a part of the HP fandom (may still be, in fact) but there’s no way you can wrap your head around how big it is unless you read this book. I am what you would call a giant HP fan. I read the first book right after it was published here. I happened to be in New York the month after it came out and saw it on a display at Books of Wonder. I had no idea what it was about. An employee saw me pick it up and said “I’m reading that – it’s pretty good so far.” I thought, what the heck? Melissa came to the party a long time after I did, but she’s the one with her finger on the pulse of the whole thing.
It’s a fascinating story, and for me, it completes a picture. I recommend it wholeheartedly. Melissa’s not only a friend, but she’s a fantastic writer and, now, a fan historian. Her book surprised me at every turn – mostly because I had no idea what to expect on any level – and now I invite you to be surprised as well. Pick it up – if you love HP, I don’t think you’ll be sorry you did.
Order from your local independent bookstore or from Powell’s.

February 20th, 2009 - 8:57 pm
Saw this at Target & almost bought it. Guess I’ll have to make another trip!
February 21st, 2009 - 8:40 am
Yay! I haven’t read it yet, but it is on my list. *sniff* I can’t believe we knew her when.
February 21st, 2009 - 4:24 pm
Melissa, it’s so odd to see you review a book I wrote. Thank you so much for the kind words. Honestly, this entire exercise, along with many other things, has continued to teach me how only those whose words you respect are valuable to you in any way. Thanks for being someone whose words I respect, and thanks for being someone whose words ended up being nice.
As to those who don’t get it’s at least half memoir, I don’t consider their reactions worth pondering (and one day in person I’ll explain to you why there is a small group of people who seem to think lavishing an inordinate amount of negative attention on me will do anything but make me think they are in serious need of better things to do with their time). I don’t think any careful or considerate reader can miss the fact that this is part memoir or be OMGSHOCKED when they discover that fact, and the only reactions I care about are those of careful and considerate readers. Luckily my readers are both things, in spades; I can’t even tell you the volume of e-mail I’m getting these days, and how each letter is of such fantastic quality that for that alone I consider myself successful. Anyway, as always, there are many who make it their aim to be as dulled/inconsiderate/uncareful as possible about this book, but I always knew going in that there would be. If there weren’t, I would have taken that as a note that it did not hit a critical mass of Potter fans.
It’s such a joy when friends say they’ve enjoyed the book. That is seriously the best part of this entire enterprise. I just, as I was writing this, got a text message from another friend who just finished it. That I’ve written something my friends enjoy brings me a great warmth that no idiot on Amazon can cool.
I swear I’m coming out to NJ to see that gorgeous daughter of yours and catch up.
xxx,
M
February 25th, 2009 - 8:59 am
I stopped by my local independent bookseller yesterday and placed an order for this book. Can’t wait to read it!
February 25th, 2009 - 11:22 am
E, it’s going to make you wish someone (Melissa?) would write one for RENT.
March 1st, 2009 - 3:01 pm
I’ve been reading this book all weekend, and you are right. It’s excellent and hard to put down.